Harav Yosef Carmel
How stirring were Moshe?s words to Bnei Yisrael: ?Stand and see Hashem?s
salvation ? Hashem will fight for you, and you shall be silent? (Shemot 14:
13-14). It is wonderful to be assured that pending doom will turn into
salvation. However, one can ask whether standing silently as Hashem did
miracles was ideal. Would it have been better or worse if Moshe had told
them to take up arms and fend off the enemy as they later did against Amalek
(ibid. 17:9)? On the other hand, what more can one ask for then a miraculous
battle fought by Hashem Himself? That way, they avoided the unpleasant, even
if necessary, job of killing the enemy. To borrow R. Shimon?s phrase: ?If
they merited, their work was done by others.?
The midrash (Eicha Rabbati), in another context, demonstrates that
participation is the higher level. The midrash contrasts the approach to
impending battle of four prominent Kings of Israel. David asked of Hashem:
?I shall chase my enemies, and I shall catch up to them? (Tehillim 18:38).
Hashem enabled him to do so. One of the early kings of the Davidic dynasty,
Assa, turned to Hashem and said: ?I do not have the strength to kill my
enemies. Rather, I will chase them, and You will kill them.? The midrash
proves that this request was also granted. Yehoshafat admitted: ?I do not
have the strength to chase the enemy. Rather, I will sing songs of praise,
and You will do everything.? This too was done. The last of the kings
mentioned, Chizkiyahu, said something mind-boggling: ?I do not have strength
to kill or chase or sing songs of praise. Rather, I will sleep on my bed,
and You will do.? Indeed, as Chizkiyahu slept, Hashem?s plague destroyed
Sancherev?s whole army.
The midrash?s language and context demonstrates that this is an
illustration of yeridat hadorot, an erosion in people?s level from one
generation to the next. David?s approach was the healthiest of the four. He
merited taking an active in role in fighting for/with Hashem, as Avigayil
said: ?For my master does fight the wars of Hashem.? The least commendable
of the four is Chizkiyahu, who did not even have the strength to properly
sing to Hashem. In fact, Hashem was willing to make that battle the
apocalyptic war and Chizkiyahu would have been Mashiach had he sung songs of
praise (Shir Hashirim Rabbah 4).
Let us return to Yam Suf. After seeing endless miracles, the nation
still complained, ?It would have been better to be slaves to Egypt.? By
doing so, they lost the right not only to fight but even to sing to Hashem
as He prepared to save them, as Moshe declared: ?Hashem will fight for you,
and you will be silent.? Only the self-sacrifice and belief of entering the
sea enabled them to sing. As we say in tefilla: ?A new song sang the
liberated on the shores of the sea.?
In our generation, which is one which put its lives on the line many
times, let us pray that we will merit to sing the song of ultimate

2 thoughts on “Standing Motionless Is Moving in Which Direction?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *